@Indradhanush
Inactive
19
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
19/7
Premature elimination of Shashi has left me wondering, what went wrong with his singing. He picked up a nice song (mere piya to hai pardes by NFAK saab) and executed it well. But Asha ji was turned off probably because he sang it in Ekar..! For Asha ji singing in Aakar is very important.
Going by this any one singing NFAK song will not get a go ahead easily esp if he doesn't sing it in his style.
18/7
I am actually confused about what factors are being considerd by Ahsa tai.
She gave green signal to Zaheer (aur kya ahade wafa hote hai) while holding Shashi (mujhe kuch kahna hai) and Tarun (Meri Zindagi by NFAK) back.
If it is totally dependent on sur then Zaheer is fine because he was most sureela but he was sounding completely like Suresh Wadekar saab through out. Asha tai herself has been saying that one must sing in his style (actually said this to Debojeet).
May be Shashi was held because his high sur was strained ( though a good attempt) but Tarun was attempting a very difficult song of NFAK yes he missed few sur but some of his harkat and taan were fantastic, feel and emotion also was very good.
Naina was the only female singer up to the mark.
I think there are factors beyond comprehension of lay rasiks like us which Asha tai can see and we can't.
Other singers were un impressive and need to work hard.
Edited by Indradhanush - 16 years ago
Created
16years
Last reply
16years
Replies
25
Views
2k
Users
9
Frequent Posters
Sort Replies:
@Indradhanush
Inactive
19
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
May be I think very good voice quality of Zaheer went in his favour.
Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn andcontribute.
LoginRegister
@m_khan90
Voyager
15
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
Originally posted by: Indradhanush
May be I think very good voice quality of Zaheer went in his favour.
I think you are right. Zaheer's voice quality is very nice and he is voice is very sureily. I listen to his other Dubai rendition, totally awsume.
I liked Tarun's voice too but I think Ashaji liked to listen one more time to Tarun. He will definetly be selected tomorrow. Shashi's voice is nice too but when he sings I feel that his voice is drowning. I think that kind of voice is good for Talat Mahmood's type of songs.
@Indradhanush
Inactive
19
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
right khan saab. Anither thing which Asha tai once again mentioned like last year is singing in aakar and ekar, I hope some one from forum sheds light on this, Actually the girl getting golden key got a lot of praise because she was singing in aakar.
@Indradhanush
Inactive
19
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
any idea on why Shashi got eliminated...?
@-shehzaadi-
Rocker
28
Posted: 16 years ago
#6
i personally didn't want Shashi to be eliminated...oh well, there is still some hope for him because of the sanjeevani booti.
@m_khan90
Voyager
15
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
Originally posted by: Indradhanush
any idea on why Shashi got eliminated...?
In my yesterday's post I mention that Shashi will be in danger zone & could be eliminated. The reason being Shashi was in the wrong group of boys. Debojit, Tarun & Shashi. The judges openly favour Debojit so he could not be eliminated (Today he sings nicely though). Tarun sings nice but can be used for drama as well so he could be eliminated. The one who is left is Shashi, so he is eliminated. One good thing is Shashi can come back at the later stage not like Snehandu who has to packed his bags.
@Indradhanush
Inactive
19
Posted: 16 years ago
#8
yes khan you mentioned yesterday and I didn't believe you then.
Some how Debojit got away with not so good singing while shashi suffered. Tarun's choice of sawan me lag gayi aag was pathetic and some one should have pointed at this.
His approach says that he has been singing in orchestra since some time. Tarun was good and deserved to go ahead.
For some reason DD is favoured by judges (which we don't know of course my opinion only)
@Anuradha
Inactive
32
+ 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#9
Shashi's elimination was fully pre-planned.. Its evident from Himesh and Aadesh's comments.. He was just too good, yet he was eliminated.. Maybe they felt he could be the best choice for sanjeevni bhooti... Dont know why they brought all the good singers on one go..
@Indradhanush
Inactive
19
Posted: 16 years ago
#10
Originally posted by: Anuradha
Shashi's elimination was fully pre-planned.. Its evident from Himesh and Aadesh's comments.. He was just too good, yet he was eliminated.. Maybe they felt he could be the best choice for sanjeevni bhooti... Dont know why they brought all the good singers on one go..
But Sanjeevani it self is not straight forward there will be 3 singers and only one selected. I just hope wea re not left with less talented singers towards the end.
But again we can see in each episode there is 50 % mediocre singing and only 50 % worth our vivechna (attention).
1 2 3
No Related topics found